I really enjoyed this book, a must read for any Mats fan. APL also has a great box set of all Mats studio recordings. I never saw a Bob show but, this book made me go out and watch a lot of video. Very thorough without being boring or pompous.
I enjoyed this book very much and learned their reputation was based on reality. Some antics were funny but many were simply tragic...they were afraid of success, yet jealous of other band's successes. (I really got upset about smashing beautiful guitars....C'mon!) The stories about their upbringing; broken families, alcoholism, divorce, and much, much worse are real American stories. Despite their tendencies to sabotage their careers, the 'Mats left a small but great legacy of great rock songs. (Check out Let It Be, Tim, Pleased to Meet Me)
I liked the band. Didn't have the end-all devotion that most in this city (Minneapolis) had but I liked them. Only saw them live once and that was just for a handful of songs. Thanks to author Bob Mehr, I learned that this performance was the first that Paul Westerberg did without the influence of alcohol. And it's this attention to detail and backstory why Bob Mehr deserves some massive kudos for this book. At over 400 pages, this really goes beyond what one would expect from a music bio. Especially when most folks, band members probably included, think that's just completely overblown for this little engine that could but didn't. This story is much more compelling than you'd think. It's not just the tall-tales that have followed the band over the years. Childhood upbringings, perspectives from others within the circle, and first accounts of just how they felt about each other are thoroughly covered in details that can be both hilarious and heartbreaking. You end up realizing that the only thing that constantly stopped The Replacements from reaching that next level of success, was The Replacements. This is actually one of the better music biographies I have read in quite a while. Like I said, kudos to you Mr. Mehr.
I am embarrassingly unfamiliar with The Replacements. I'm sure there are a handful of songs that I know, and even more that I've heard a million times and just never realized or cared that it was them. I actually had no intention of reading this book, at least not now; I downloaded it on the new Kindle I purchased for my trip to see the Truckers and began reading it only as a test. Huge credit to author Mehr for making the first chapters interesting enough to grip my attention and make me commit! Despite not being a fan of the 'Mats, I am a huge fan of many bands who credit them as an inspiration. This book really put into perspective the influence they've had (like the Drive-By Truckers' ear-bleeding volume, or Lucero's loose and sloppy setlists). I'm not convinced they'll become a new favorite band, but I'm definitely eager to devour their catalog. I definitely recommend this one.
Good book about The Replacements- has some interesting details about the rats that run the music business.
I've read a few other books about the Replacements but this is the most well rounded. Solid interviews by the author and research and little knowledgeable tidbits about the scene and Minneapolis really takes this book beyond its peers. I highly recommend it for any 'Mats fan.
The book also finally convinced me that some bands just has a natural lifespan. By the time the Replacements got past their self-destructive phase, Chris Mars was halfway out the door and more focused on art and Bob Stinson – the rocker, was already gone. Nothing against Paul Westerberg, but the book really demonstrated to me he was better in a band than as a solo artist and there was something special and fleeting about the 'Mats. Something that will never be recreated in a Westerberg solo effort or in a Stinson/Westerberg reunion.
Exhaustive (and exhausting) book about The Mats. The Replacement could've been the best rock'n'roll band in the world, but they habitually turfed their career any chance they got. This book shines a light on the legend....
Terrifically entertaining read even if you are not familiar with the band. Meticulously researched, full of surprises, author Bob Mehr even got the notoriously uncooperative remaining members to give an honest accounting of the wild ride that was the Replacements. Funny and heartbreaking!
There are no ages for this title yet.
There are no summaries for this title yet.
There are no notices for this title yet.
There are no quotes for this title yet.