Not Currently Available

Average Rating:
Rate this:


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Feb 25, 2019

8th title in the Isabel Dahlhousie series (total of 12 in the series thru 2018).
Author Alexander McCall Smith captures the insights of "intelligent information and reflection". I'd guess that some readers lose patience with his educated style of writing.
This plot is less intense that some of the earlier stores; less intense is okay.
This plot is good reading;
I enjoy the characteristics described about Grace, the keeper of the home's well-being. And the descriptions of toddler Charlie are sweet.
The fact that I really know little about Scotland's history makes me a typical reader.

Sep 23, 2012

This is another delightful outing with Isabel Dalhousie. McCall Smith writes such mannered lovely prose and writes it so engagingly. I loved the part when Charlie says a naughty word beginning with "s", and the playschool teacher is so mortified she won't even say it so she writes it down: "And underneath was written a word in common use among builders, soldiers, teenagers and novelists." Haha! - but not this novelist! He's so genteel.... I kind of wanted Charlie to be caught saying it again, on a day when Grace was picking him up, and her talk to him about it, and see what Isabel and Jamie did with that. - Also liked the mushroom scene and the quote, "There are old mycologists and there are bold mycologists, but there are no old, bold mycologists"! So many treasures in here, and in every Dalhousie novel (and the Precious Ramotswe ones, too). How does he do it? and long may he continue!

Jul 29, 2012

I always like Smith's books about Isabel Dalhousie. Not only a nice story, but also shows a slice of Scottish life. The mystery is easygoing - just a little life mystery, not murder and mayhem that so many mysteries are.

melwyk May 01, 2012

Once again, an enjoyable visit with Isabel and her peculiarly individual thought patterns..... these books are very quotable and very thought-provoking, though some of the characters (ie: Cat!) are so annoying! So great to be able to read another episode in Isabel's story, and the only problem now is waiting for the next one ;)

Apr 08, 2012

Always enjoyable to spend a few quiet hours mulling over the great moral issues that always seem to underscore the seemingly small, inconsequential events that make up a normal day in our modern lives. Best read sitting curled up in a comfy chair with a cup of tea.

AuntJane Mar 12, 2012

A wonderful read. So nice to return to Edinburgh with Isabel Dalhousie and her intellectual musings on philosphy, art, music, poetry, relationships, Brother Fox, you name it!

Jan 09, 2012

One of the more moving Isabel Dalhousie stories


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further


Find it at ALCO

To Top